Product Description

Embrace autumn vibes with our Pumpkin Cookie, a sweet delight perfect for fall.

Ingredients
vanilla
- flour
- water
- sugar
- margarine
- baking powder
- vanilla sugar
- vanilla extract
- eggs
- dried egg whites
- food coloring
Ingredients
ginger
- flour
- eggs
- baking soda
- cinnamon
- honey
- vinegar
- oil
- sugar
- margarine
- ginger
- food coloring
Ingredients
chocolate
- chocolate
- margarine
- sugar
- confection sugar
- cappuccino flavor

Also for Test Collection

Engagement/Wedding Ring Cookies

$4.50

Per Decorated Cookie

MADE JUST FOR YOU

Name: Pumpkin Cookie
Brand: CustomCookies.com
SKU: THA1051-1
Price: 4.5 USD
Availability: InStock

Handcrafted

Each treat is designed, formed and decorated individually by hand

Personalized

From shape, to flavor, to color palette and more - we do it all your way.

Delicious

Your treats are prepared by a team of pastry chefs and artists, using only fresh, premium ingredients.

Packed Safe & Snug

Our packers wrap your batch with care, ensuring they arrive fresh and fully intact with no breakage or damage along the way.

From happy customers

B. T.

Bridget Trau

So accommodating, helpful, and patient! Custom Cookies completely exceed our expectations.

D. H.

Debra Halperin

Insane talent. Incredibly delicious and the design is out of this world!

N. L.

Nicole Lewis

This is my ‘go-to’ place for every single event and party! Excellent customer service and incredible products. They customize every order to fit my theme, color scheme, and personal preferences. An absolute delight to work with.

S. D.

Sasha David

On both occasions, Custom Cookies were attentive and flexible with my requests. They have the best in price and quality out of the multiple custom cookie places I looked into! Highly recommended!

T. M.

Terry Moore

Absolutely adorable, delicious, and delivered right on time! Loads of thought went into this — each cookie came individually wrapped with a ribbon. Will definitely be using Custom Cookies again.

V. B.

Vivian Bloughery

My clients raged over these treats! As an event planner, there are minute details that make a huge difference. Custom Cookies went the extra mile to accommodate my requests and delivered spectacular results. Will be using them again. And again.

B. T.

Bridget Trau

So accommodating, helpful, and patient! Custom Cookies completely exceed our expectations.

D. H.

Debra Halperin

Insane talent. Incredibly delicious and the design is out of this world!

N. L.

Nicole Lewis

S. D.

Sasha David

On both occasions, Custom Cookies were attentive and flexible with my requests. They have the best in price and quality out of the multiple custom cookie places I looked into! Highly recommended!

T. M.

Terry Moore

Absolutely adorable, delicious, and delivered right on time! Loads of thought went into this — each cookie came individually wrapped with a ribbon. Will definitely be using Custom Cookies again.

V. B.

Vivian Bloughery

B. T.

Bridget Trau

So accommodating, helpful, and patient! Custom Cookies completely exceed our expectations.

D. H.

Debra Halperin

Insane talent. Incredibly delicious and the design is out of this world!

Follow us on Instagram @customcookiesny

CustomCookies.com

5.0

95 reviews

5 Star Ratingby Christina M

a month ago

5 Star Ratingby Kate B

3 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Crystal X

3 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Jackie R

3 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Anna P

4 months ago

CustomCookies.com

5.0

95 reviews

5 Star Ratingby Kaleen H

7 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Rivky T

3 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Chana F

3 years ago

5 Star Ratingby Libby

2 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Talia N

Edited 11 months ago

CustomCookies.com

5.0

95 reviews

5 Star Ratingby Rachel D

9 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Samantha R

10 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Sandra C

2 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Hudi G

a year ago

5 Star Ratingby Joel G

9 months ago

CustomCookies.com

5.0

95 reviews

5 Star Ratingby Michele M

a month ago

5 Star Ratingby chaim S

a year ago

5 Star Ratingby Terry M

3 years ago

5 Star Ratingby Fruma G

4 months ago

5 Star Ratingby Lee A

9 months ago

CustomCookies.com

5.0

95 reviews on

AI Summary

Based on 95 reviews

Exceptional quality and taste: Customers consistently highlight the delicious flavor and beautiful presentation of the cookies and treats, indicating a high level of craftsmanship;

Outstanding customer service: Many reviews praise the company's prompt and helpful communication, showcasing their dedication to addressing customer needs and ensuring satisfaction;

Customization options: The ability to tailor orders to specific themes and color schemes is frequently mentioned, making these treats ideal for various events and celebrations.

Christina M

a month ago

Verified

Thrilled with our custom cookie order. Not only were they beautiful, but they were also very tasty. Incredibly fresh and well- made and the delivery arrived early!! They were also incredibly professional when I reached out to them. I would definitely recommend their treats. They can expect more orders from us.

Kate B

3 months ago

Verified

Perfect for parties and special events! Delicious and ever artistic! The basketball cookies even had the raised bumps like real basketballs! The cake pops were also a crowd favorite!!! I can’t recommend Custom Cookies enough. I’ve been a repeat customer for three years now!

Crystal X

3 months ago

Verified

Incredibly easy to order online! Call or email with questions and they respond super quickly. Cookie design and quality were so worth the price. Will be buying from them again for our next event!

Jackie R

3 months ago

Verified

Great company! Super communicative and helpful with my custom order — Toby provided quotes quickly, updated a shipping address last minute, and offered insightful recommendations. The cookies themselves were packed so thoughtfully (for shipping and personally transporting), unbelievably charming, and delicious. My family was blown away by the quality, both in look and taste. Highly recommend and look forward to using this company again.

Anna P

4 months ago

Verified

I ordered the Chocolate dipped pretzels for my daughter’s Baby Boy shower. They were delivered in time, packaged extremely well. Not one broken! They were beautiful and delicious! So thankful! They were a hit with my guests! I would not hesitate to order in the future!

Kaleen H

7 months ago

Verified

This company is just the absolute BEST! The fastest turn over time ever. I was in a immediate bind and needed 1500 CUSTOM sweet treats in 4 DAYS. They were more than accommodating and delivered on time. Beyond grateful everyone enjoyed and it was perfect!

Rivky T

3 months ago

Verified

I used Custom Cookies for my son's birthday party. They came through with flying colors! They followed the colors and theme perfectly, sending us the most gorgeous cookies, delivered everything on time. Super talented and superb service!

Chana F

3 years ago

Verified

Custom Cookies is my “go to place” to make every one of my parties personal and beautiful. Their customer service and their work is truly incredible. They customize every order to fit my theme and color scheme. They honestly make me, as an event planner, look so good! I love working with them!

Libby

2 months ago

Verified

Great customer service, best pricing, and best in taste, highly recommend! We ordered for our friend who made upsherin, made such a statement!

Talia N

Edited 11 months ago

Verified

Absolutely breathtaking desserts. If your searching for kosher masterpieces search no longer.. Also got macaroons in the shape of shells and pretzels with sea shells all eaten before I could pic. Fondant was best i’ve ever had tasted DELICIOUS! ALWAYS THE BEST!

Rachel D

9 months ago

Verified

So so happy with their cookies and their work! Used them for my son’s first birthday and bris and they are STUNNING every time!!! So impressed. The detail 😱

Samantha R

10 months ago

Verified

This is my third time buying cookies from Custom Cookies! They are delicious and gorgeous. There was a small mixup with the cookies this time, and they went above and beyond with fixing it. Highly recommend to anyone who is looking for beautiful, reasonably priced, custom cookies.

Sandra C

2 months ago

Verified

I loved these cookies! They are delicious and so gorgeous!!

Hudi G

a year ago

Verified

Such a great product!! We ordered for my daughter's Bat Mitzvah and they were able to customize every aspect of the products to exactly the color and theme we had at the party. ty!! And they tasted great too :)

Joel G

9 months ago

Verified

I ordered my corporate gifts for this year's Holiday season at CustomCookies. It was a great success! Shipped directly to all my clients, packaged beautifully in their signature gift wrapping and boxes. All my clients really enjoyed them and actually mentioned that they hope to be getting them again next year! Looks and tastes Fabulous!

Michele M

a month ago

Verified

I ordered pretzels for my daughter’s baby shower and the customer service was excellent and the pretzels were delicious! Everyone loved them!! Thank you!

chaim S

a year ago

Verified

Wow. The best custom cookies in New York. Tri state area Beautiful design Delicious taste Great customer service We ordered many different times for many different occasions. We were always happy. Thank you so much

Terry M

3 years ago

Verified

I have used Custom Cookies on 2 separate occasions and they are always incredibly attentive, flexible and the final cookies/cake pops are always a huge hit. They made my wife's book launch a tremendous success. Everyone has raved at the quality and look of Custom Cookies work. And after researching multiple custom cookie places, they were the best quality and best price around! Highly recommended!

Fruma G

4 months ago

Verified

We used custom cookies recently for an event and were blown away by their professionalism. They were a pleasure to work with and the cookies came out stunning.

Lee A

9 months ago

Verified

I chose to use their FedEx delivery service for my event. When the box of cookies was lost, they immediately went into problem solving mode. They ended up remaking my order and hand delivered to my event. They were helpful and went above and beyond to get me my order on time. Will definitely use them again!

Pumpkin Cookie

Fastest Delivery : November 7th

Sealed Cellophane Bag

Bag With Matching Ribbon

Bag With Ribbon

Giftbox with Matching Ribbon

Product Description

Also for Test Collection

Round Logo Cookie

Rectangle Logo Cookie

Engagement/Wedding Ring Cookies

Square Logo Cookie

Floral Heart Cookie

Graduation Cap Cookie

Baby Girl Stroller Cookie

Bridal Gown Cookies

Personalized Heart Cookie

Logo Rice Crispy Treats

Rosh Hashanah Deluxe Gift box

Baby Boy Cake Pops

Handcrafted

Personalized

Delicious

Packed Safe & Snug

From happy customers

B. T.

D. H.

N. L.

S. D.

T. M.

V. B.

B. T.

D. H.

N. L.

S. D.

T. M.

V. B.

B. T.

D. H.

Pumpkin Cookie

Fastest Delivery : November 7th

Sealed Cellophane Bag

Bag With Matching Ribbon

Bag With Ribbon

Giftbox with Matching Ribbon

Product Description

Create Something Similar

I would like to create something similar to this product

I would like to create something similar to this product

Request a Quote

Pumpkin Cookie

Also for Test Collection

MADE JUST FOR YOU

Handcrafted

Personalized

Delicious

Packed Safe & Snug

From happy customers

N. L.

Follow us on Instagram @customcookiesny

Thank you for subscribing!

Order a Sample

Decorated Cookies

I would like to create something
similar to this product