What’s fresh

Trending/Featured Items

Baking delight into every bite

From mixing bowl, to oven, to frosting and finishing, our personalized, made-to-order process is at the heart of what we deliver: edible treats and baked bouquets designed to delight, wherever they’re destined to go.

Unbox our story

Unbox our story

Our crave-able craft began with an artist, a baker - and a vision for the ultimate cookie decor.

About Us
A peek behind our treats

A peek behind our treats

Custom Cookies are works of heart, and at our heart is a team of artists and pastry chefs, solely focused on crafting delight into every bite.

Step Inside the Bakery

Recent Creations

Recent Creation
Recent Creation
Recent Creation

Crunchable numbers

30+

years
baking

82k+

thrilled
customers

6k

unique design
elements

Infinite

design
possibilities

From happy customers

N. L.

Nicole Lewis

This is my ‘go-to’ place for every single event and party! Excellent customer service and incredible products. They customize every order to fit my theme, color scheme, and personal preferences. An absolute delight to work with.

S. D.

Sasha David

On both occasions, Custom Cookies were attentive and flexible with my requests. They have the best in price and quality out of the multiple custom cookie places I looked into! Highly recommended!

T. M.

Terry Moore

Absolutely adorable, delicious, and delivered right on time! Loads of thought went into this — each cookie came individually wrapped with a ribbon. Will definitely be using Custom Cookies again.

V. B.

Vivian Bloughery

My clients raged over these treats! As an event planner, there are minute details that make a huge difference. Custom Cookies went the extra mile to accommodate my requests and delivered spectacular results. Will be using them again. And again.

B. T.

Bridget Trau

So accommodating, helpful, and patient! Custom Cookies completely exceed our expectations.

D. H.

Debra Halperin

Insane talent. Incredibly delicious and the design is out of this world!

×
testimonial image
Sally Markson Location Here

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nunc pellentesque et elit in luctus. Proin sed orci iaculis, tincidunt leo nec, varius mauris. In scelerisque augue eget viverra varius. Fusce volutpat felis eu odio tristique lobortis. Aenean accumsan tincidunt nibh. Maecenas ultricies enim maximus dolor ultricies varius. Integer ut ante sagittis, viverra felis eget, eleifend sem. Fusce vitae posuere arcu. Nunc tempor faucibus tellus, ut interdum tellus vulputate ac. Quisque in lectus quis massa aliquet pharetra a ac odio. Suspendisse nec urna dictum lacus varius mollis. Nullam sit amet arcu a orci mollis pulvinar. Nullam eget pretium arcu. Vestibulum in tempor justo. In in urna odio. Integer non felis erat. Vivamus aliquet risus a tincidunt aliquam. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia curae.

Follow us on Instagram @customcookiesny